D2P vs Segment 3DPrint
AI Verdict
Choose D2P if…
Choose D2P if your primary need is an FDA-cleared, comprehensive solution for converting diverse 2D medical imaging into highly accurate 3D anatomical models for advanced visualization and surgical planning. Its deep learning capabilities and extensive 3D model editing tools, coupled with VR visualization, make it ideal for complex patient-specific surgical preparation and seamless integration within a broader 3D Systems printing ecosystem.
View D2P →Choose Segment 3DPrint if…
Choose Segment 3DPrint if you require specialized AI-driven segmentation for specific anatomical structures, such as congenital heart defects or skull defects for cranioplasty, and need robust tools for multi-modality image fusion. Its dedicated module for cranioplasty design and built-in QA wizard are particularly beneficial for point-of-care 3D printing operations requiring stringent quality management system compliance.
View Segment 3DPrint →When choosing between D2P by 3D Systems and Segment 3DPrint by Medviso AB, physicians should consider their primary use case and existing infrastructure. Both tools excel at converting 2D medical imaging data (DICOM) into 3D digital anatomical models for advanced visualization and 3D printing, leveraging AI for segmentation. However, their key practical differences lie in their feature sets and ecosystem integration.
D2P offers a comprehensive suite for detailed 3D model editing, including tools for smoothing, thickening, and hollowing, alongside seamless integration with 3D Systems’ own printers and software. It also features VR visualization for non-diagnostic use. This makes D2P particularly well-suited for users deeply embedded in the 3D Systems ecosystem or those requiring extensive post-segmentation model manipulation and a robust VR visualization component. Physicians focused on specialties like Neurosurgery and Orthopedics, who may benefit from intricate model adjustments for surgical planning, might find D2P more aligned with their needs.
In contrast, Segment 3DPrint emphasizes fast and reliable AI-based segmentation for a broader range of anatomical structures, including specialized modules for cranioplasty design and a built-in QA wizard for QMS-compliant reporting. Its fusion tool for registering MR and CT images is also a notable feature. Segment 3DPrint is deployed on-premise with a standard PC setup, offering flexibility for point-of-care 3D printing. Physicians prioritizing rapid, AI-driven segmentation across diverse anatomies, particularly those in Plastic Surgery or those needing robust QA reporting and image fusion capabilities, may find Segment 3DPrint to be the more appropriate choice.
Reviewed by Pouyan Golshani, MD — Interventional Radiologist
Quick Comparison
| Feature | D2P | Segment 3DPrint |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Contact for pricing | Contact for details |
| Deployment | Stand-alone modular software package (workstation-based) | On-premise (standard PC setup) |
| FDA Status | Yes AI-estimated | 1 AI-estimated |
Head-to-Head
AI-generated assessment across six dimensions based on each tool's documented features and compliance posture. Grounded in public data — not a substitute for hands-on evaluation.
Usability
D2PD2P by 3D Systems emphasizes consolidating all 3D model segmentation and preparation steps into a single workstation, aiming to minimize the need for technical expertise and simplify the workflow for healthcare professionals. Its seamless integration with 3D Systems' own printers and software, along with VR visualization, further streamlines the user experience within their ecosystem. While Segment 3DPrint also highlights an intuitive interface and recent usability improvements, D2P's focus on comprehensive workflow consolidation and ease of adoption gives it a slight edge.
Clinical Value
D2PBoth tools are FDA-cleared and facilitate the creation of high-quality anatomical models for surgical planning and personalized patient care. D2P has undergone specific validation studies for accuracy and usability, with its models cleared for diagnostic use when paired with validated 3D Systems printers and materials across a broad range of medical specialties. While Segment 3DPrint also reports high accuracy and leverages deep learning for reproducible segmentation, D2P's extensive validation and its unique position as a provider of both FDA-cleared software and compatible printers for diagnostic models offer a more comprehensive clinical value proposition.
Pricing & Value
TieBoth D2P and Segment 3DPrint have opaque pricing models, requiring direct contact with their respective sales teams for details. Segment 3DPrint mentions offering 'flexible license terms', but without specific pricing information or detailed licensing structures for either product, it is impossible to conduct a meaningful head-to-head comparison of their pricing and overall value.
Enterprise Readiness
D2P3D Systems, the company behind D2P, is a significantly larger and more established global entity with a broader portfolio of 3D printing solutions and extensive professional services, including training and printer service plans. D2P is part of an ecosystem that includes a cloud-based surgical planning portal (VSP Connect) for enhanced collaboration and AI-driven workflows, indicating robust enterprise capabilities. While Medviso AB is an established company with FDA clearance and a focus on quality management, 3D Systems' larger scale and comprehensive support infrastructure suggest greater enterprise readiness.
Innovation
D2PBoth tools utilize AI and deep learning for advanced segmentation, which is a key innovation in medical imaging. However, D2P explicitly integrates 'Virtual Reality (VR) visualization' and a 'volumetric VR solution' for advanced visualization, surgical planning, and patient communication, offering a distinct innovative edge in how medical data is interacted with. While Segment 3DPrint offers specialized features like a fusion tool and a dedicated cranioplasty module, D2P's broader application of VR for visualization provides a more impactful innovation for enhancing clinical understanding.
Support & Docs
D2P3D Systems, as a large, established company, offers a more extensive range of support resources, including professional services, comprehensive training, and dedicated printer service plans, which are critical for a complete 3D printing workflow in a healthcare setting. They provide detailed installation guides, system requirements, and user manuals. While Medviso also offers user manuals, FAQs, and tutorial videos, the sheer breadth of resources and the established global support network of 3D Systems provide a more robust and scalable support infrastructure.
Feature-by-Feature
Detail beyond the Quick Comparison summary. For pricing, deployment, BAA, FDA, and HIPAA see the Overview tab.
| Feature | D2P | Segment 3DPrint |
|---|---|---|
| Company | 3D Systems | Medviso AB |
| Primary Segmentation Method | Automatic and manual segmentation tools (deep learning driven) | Fast and reliable AI-based segmentation for bones, vessels, organs (e.g., orbit, mandible, teeth, lungs, trachea, congenital heart) |
| 3D Model Editing Tools | smoothing, thickening, thinning, trimming, hollow, shell, coloring, strength, labeling | Interactive 3D preview and editing of segmented objects, tools for splitting objects, adding labels, and support structures, Dedicated module for designing skull defect models for cranioplasty, Surface mesh, lattice, and honeycomb generation |
| Visualization/VR | Virtual Reality (VR) visualization for non-diagnostic use, High-quality volume rendering and mesh coloring | Interactive 3D preview |
| Supported Imaging Modalities | CT, MR, CBCT | Implied MR and CT (from fusion tool), but not explicitly listed as general modalities |
| Output/Export Formats | STL, OBJ, PLY, DXF, IGES, 3DS, OBJ, VRML, PLY, XYZ | Not specified |
| Specialties | Neurosurgery, Orthopedics, Radiology | Neurosurgery, Plastic Surgery, Radiology |
Videos
Demos, reviews, and walkthroughs featuring D2P and Segment 3DPrint.